100% Affordable Housing Project in Trouble as Zoning Board Fixates on Parking

On paper, the proposal that came before the Jersey City Zoning Board of Adjustment on November 5 was a civic triumph: a project delivering 40 affordable for-sale homes on the border of Bergen-Lafayette. The project, 64 Sackett Street, would use state grants and down-payment assistance to bring purchase prices into the $200,000 range for these family-sized homes. Seventy percent of the condos would be designated for households in the very-low-to-moderate-income bands, and 30% for families in the workforce housing band. Even the city’s planning staff marveled at the project, noting that in a landscape dominated by market-rate rentals, an all-affordable condo development of this scale is virtually unprecedented in New Jersey. The site is an 8-minute walk from a light rail station and a supermarket, allowing residents access to jobs and amenities without the need to hop in a car.

Yet, at the last Zoning Board meeting, the commissioners set the stage to slam the prospective doors on future homeownership for 40 families, because of the single most destructive obsession in American municipal zoning: car storage. In the battle between space for working-class families versus space for cars, will the cars win?

Exterior rendering of a four-story, 40-unit residential building at 64–74 Sackett Street in Jersey City, New Jersey.

The procedural irony at 64 Sackett Street borders on parody. The applicant could have built 40 units without parking as-of-right under Jersey City’s Affordable Housing Overlay as a three-story, lot-covering mass; residents on the second and third floors would need to be able to climb stairs since there would be no elevator. Instead, at the explicit urging of city planning staff, the architects, T LaPorta Architect, reconfigured the proposal into a four-story building with a smaller footprint and more distance from neighbors. Going up just nine feet created wider side yards, expanded backyard green space, and made space for an elevator that rendered every single unit fully accessible to people with disabilities.

But that height adjustment pushed the project from the Planning Board into the discretionary territory of the Zoning Board. Suddenly, it became vulnerable to the entire gauntlet of local obstruction and micromanaging design by committee.

Under Jersey City’s zoning ordinance, 100% affordable developments carry an explicit minimum parking requirement of zero. That exemption codifies basic economic reality into law. Constructing structured parking in North Jersey routinely adds $30,000 to $40,000 per stall to capital costs, according to Jersey City planner Matt Ward. Since the pot of state grant money for affordable housing is finite, every dollar that goes to building housing for cars is one dollar less that is used to house human beings. Each parking stall and its associated circulation space takes up over 300 square feet, about a third the size of a two-bedroom apartment [Jackwin]. To put it starkly: each 3 parking spots built displace a family of 3 from a home.

None of that mattered on the dais. Board commissioners immediately fixated on neighborhood street parking, dismissing the ordinance’s deliberate exemption and treating the lack of garages as an unforgivable offense.

When the developer explained that the project met state standards and provided homes for low- and moderate-income households, Commissioner Kathleen D’Angelo pushed back with overt skepticism. Learning that 30% of the homes were designated for workforce earners, she interjected, “Those people can afford cars.” When told the project offered homeownership rather than tenancy, she doubled down: “If they’re condos, those people will probably definitely will have a car or something. I mean, if you can afford a condo, you can afford a car.” Simply speaking, d’Angelo’s statements are belied by the stats: between 2014 and 2024, the number of zero-car households in Jersey City increased by about 19,000, as thousands of residents have moved into new market-rate apartments in Jersey City without parking despite being able to afford cars. [US Census Bureau 1, US Census Bureau 2]

The message was unmistakable: if you are fortunate enough to purchase an entry-level subsidized condo, you should be presumed guilty of owning an automobile, and your right to an affordable roof must be conditioned on guaranteeing private parking.

D’Angelo took that logic to its reactionary conclusion, openly questioning whether she could approve the height variance without concessions on vehicle storage: “You come before us asking for another story which adds so many apartments… but I guess I’m having difficulty thinking if I should vote for this if there’s not even any other consideration to try to come up with some sort of parking even though it’s not mandated.” (Recall that a 40-unit building would have been allowed even without the variance and in fact had already been submitted [Jersey City Public Information])

The commissioner’s statement encapsulates everything broken about local land-use review. A board member, evaluating a project legally deemed an “inherently beneficial use” under New Jersey law, openly threatened to veto 40 units of deed-restricted housing because the applicant failed to comply with her guess about how much parking should be required, when the Municipal Council had deliberately chosen to abolish parking for cases such as this.

Meanwhile, Vice Chair Victor Rayo added more procedural hurdles, lamenting that the city’s Division of Traffic and Engineering had failed to supply an advisory memo, suggesting that neighborhood parking disputes ought to dictate zoning outcomes even while acknowledging that parking could not legally form the basis of a denial.

Because New Jersey’s Municipal Land Use Law requires a supermajority of five affirmative votes for a use or density variance, and only five commissioners were seated on the dais that evening, a single dissenting commissioner wielded absolute veto power. Faced with the possibility that D’Angelo would tank the application, the developer’s attorney had no choice but to retreat, carrying the matter to December in hopes of finding a full, more sensible board.

Jersey City is gripped by an acute housing shortage. Working-class families are priced out of neighborhoods they have inhabited for generations. Yet when a builder steps forward with state subsidies in hand to construct 40 affordable condos near bus lines and light rail, our municipal apparatus treats car storage as an essential human right and housing supply as an optional nuisance.

If Jersey City is serious about housing affordability, its boards must stop evaluating community vitality through the windshield of a parked car. Forty families deserve a shot at homeownership at 64 Sackett Street, and no commissioner should be allowed to hold their keys hostage over a parking space.

D’Angelo’s term on the board expired on June 30, 2026. She is serving in a holdover capacity until she is either replaced or reappointed to a new term.

Call to Action

  1. Supporters can show up to testify in favor of prioritizing housing affordability on December 8 at 6 pm in the Boardroom at the Holloway Building, City Hall Annex, 4 Jackson Square. The building is also known as 39 Kearney Avenue, Jersey City, NJ 07305.  This will be the first matter heard during the evening and testimony should happen before 6:15pm.
  2. We call on Mayor Solomon not to appoint d’Angelo to a new term on the board. You can e-mail Mayor Solomon (jsolomon@jcnj.org) and ask him not to renew Commissioner d’Angelo’s appointment.
  3. It may also be time to nip such objections to new housing in the bud by expanding Ordinance 19-150.  According to this ordinance, passed in November 2019, if new buildings in Journal Square do not provide parking, their tenants are unable to obtain street parking permits.  We would support seeing this law extended citywide.

Have any tips for stories? Want to submit articles? Email us at betterblocksnj at gmail dot com, or DM us on social media. Anonymity can be preserved if requested.

Leave a Reply